Skip to main content

Table 3 Items that did not achieved consensus

From: Essential elements to “design for dissemination” within a research network—a modified Delphi study of the Community-Academic Aging Research Network (CAARN)

Non-essential elements

Percent of panelists that considered the element as essential

Spearman correlation (Round 2 vs Round 3)

Round 1

Round 2

Round 3

 

Regarding the academic partners invited to participate in CAARN projects

• Principal Investigator (or their Mentor on the grant if they are junior) has experience doing dissemination and implementation research

50%

57%

55%

0.35

• Principal Investigator (or their Mentor on the grant, if they are junior) has experience doing community-based participatory research (CBPR)a

54%

48%

  

Regarding the community partners invited to participate in CAARN projects.

• Has experience with program evaluationa

32%

43%

  

• Belongs to a larger network of agencies

41%

33%

  

• Has previous experience participating in research activitiesa

25%

14%

  

Regarding the Community Research Associate (CRA)

• Has experience training people to serve as facilitators/leaders of health promotion programs

n/a

50%

40%

0.36

• Has research experience

54%

41%

  

• Is assertive. (Assertiveness is defined as the capacity to effectively communicate both the community and academic partner’s needs. Also, speaking on behalf of someone)b

68%

64%

75%

0.22

• Has experience with community-based participatory research (community-based participatory research (CBPR) is defined as a collaborative approach to research that equitably involves all partners in the research process and recognizes the unique strengths that each brings)a

71%

55%

65%

0.09

• Has experience facilitating (or leading) evidence-based health promotion programs in community settingsa

n/a

55%

55%

0.03

• Has experience establishing new partnerships or collaborations

n/a

71%

75%

0.22

CRA roles and responsibilities

• Facilitates team meetings AFTER the grant is obtained (Facilitating refers to leading the meeting, or providing leadership without taking the reins)a

79%

64%

55%

0.66

• Provides input on materials that are created for the implementation or dissemination of the interventionsa

68%

68%

70%

0.64

• Provides reminders to the academic and community partners about tasks and timelines related to the research processa

61%

64%

60%

0.52

• Confirms the delivery of payments, equipment, and other materials related to research activities to community organizationsa

61%

36%

  

• Provides input regarding the feasibility of the intervention and study design, implementation barriers and facilitators, and required elements for successful implementationa

64%

59%

70%

0.15

• Which of the following would be most beneficial to serve as home base for the CRA (Assuming that the home base provides all the necessary support (e.g., financial, supervision, management)ab

Academic 26%

Academic 27%

Academic 20%

0.45

Community 12%

Community 18%

 

Either 31%

Either 75%

Other: 36%

Other: 22%

Other: 5%

• CRA’s position includes non-research activities at the base organization in order to fully understand the community that they represent (meaning that they will be only part time with the research network)a b

0%

14%

  

Regarding the director of a research network like CAARN

• Has content knowledge that matches the focus of the research networka

68%

62%

65%

0.36

• Based at an academic organization in comparison to a community organizationa

67%

57%

75%

0.3

• Has experience working in clinical settings (e.g., hospitals, clinics, community health center, or other healthcare provider organization)a

39%

24%

  

Regarding the dissemination organization(s)

• Has a commitment to disseminate new programs nationally (as opposed to only in the state)a

56%

48%

45%

0.34

• Has experience developing leader trainings for evidence-based programsa

78%

48%

55%

0.51

• Engages as a stakeholder in the research stages of the project before the program is provena

75%

62%

65%

0.71

• Research network uses only one organization (as opposed to more than one) to disseminate the programs developed by the research networka

12%

14%

  

• Has experience doing research

67%

33%

  

• Be compensated for the time/effort spent in project activities performed in their role as a stakeholder

63%

38%

  

• Addresses issues related to needs of researchers as creators of the product.

 

48%

  
  1. Wording is equal to the one used in the last round where the item was included
  2. Bold: 70–79% of panelists indicated the element to be essential, but it did not achieved consensus
  3. aIndicates rewording/clarification between Round 1 and Round 2
  4. bIndicates rewording/clarification between Round 2 and Round 3