Skip to main content

Table 4 Data on implementation outcomes: acceptability, fidelity, and adoption

From: Interactive and Participatory Audit and Feedback (IPAF): theory-based development and multi-site implementation outcomes with specialty clinic staff

 

BP Connect at Clinics A, B, C

Quit Connect at Clinics A, B, C

BP Connect at Clinic Da

Quit Connect at Clinic Da

 

Mean (SD) unless otherwise indicated

bAcceptability (questionnaire)

n = 10

n = 10

n = 4

n = 6

 Listening

4.33 (1.00)

4.60 (0.52)

3.75 (0.96)

3.50 (1.38)

 Responsiveness

4.22 (0.97)

4.70 (0.48)

3.75 (0.96)

4.00 (0.63)

 Flexibility

4.22 (0.97)

NA

3.50 (1.29)

NA

 Collaboration

4.44 (0.53)

NA

3.50 (1.00)

NA

bFidelity (questionnaire)

n = 10

n = 10

n = 4

n = 6

 Respectfulness

4.90 (0.32)

4.89 (0.33)

4.00 (0)

4.67 (0.58)

 Problem solving

4.90 (0.42)

4.78 (0.44)

3.33 (0.58)

4.67 (0.58)

 Motivation from goals

3.70 (0.82)

4.56 (0.73)

2.50 (1.29)

NA

 Confidence (pre)

2.60 (1.07)

2.10 (1.10)

3.33 (0.81)

2.5 (0.55)

 Confidence (post)

4.00 (0.47)

4.30 (0.67)

3.75 (0.50)

3.67 (0.52)

cAdoption (IPAF tool/ EHR data)

 
 

n = 40

n = 32

n = 12

n = 15

 Check goals at first session

50-90%

75%-100%

NA

100%

 Check goals at last session

75-95%

75%-100%

NA

70%-100%

 Check actual at baseline

2%

3%

0%

90%

 Check actual 6 months post

98%

100%

80% peak

98%

 Connect goals at first session

50-100%

50%-95%

NA

33%-80%

 Connect goals at last session

50-100%

80-100%

NA

80%-85%

 Connect actual at baseline

0%

<1%

0%

<1%

 Connect actual 6 months post

73%

76%

68%

53% peak

  1. aBP Connect was implemented after Quit Connect in Clinic D and A&F sessions were by phone; bPre-post confidence was measured retrospectively for clinics A, B, C and prospectively for D; cConnect step: offer primary care BP follow-up or tobacco quit line phone call; Abbreviations: NA data not available