Skip to main content

Table 2 Technical efficiency scores and returns to the scale of tobacco treatment programs in C3I

From: Data envelopment analysis to evaluate the efficiency of tobacco treatment programs in the NCI Moonshot Cancer Center Cessation Initiative

 

CRS technical efficiency

VRS technical efficiency

Scale efficiency

CRS, N (%)

DRS, N (%)

All programs (n = 16)

 Mean

25.66

76.82

31.40

7 (44)

9 (56)

 SD

24.56

22.98

23.73

  

 Min

2.91

39.2

5.88

  

Cohort 1 (n = 11)

 Mean

29.15

80.46

32.54

5 (45)

6 (55)

 SD

28.65

23.21

26.92

  

 Min

2.91

46.75

5.88

  

Cohort 2 (n = 5)

 Mean

17.99

68.82

28.88

2 (40)

3 (60)

 SD

10.16

22.76

16.99

  

 Min

7.94

39.20

10.26

  

No point-of-care (n = 7)

 Mean

15.59

62.07

24.01

4 (57)

3 (43)

 SD

14.31

23.07

15.56

  

 Min

2.91

39.20

5.88

  

Point-of-care (n = 9)

 Mean

33.50

88.30

37.15

3 (33)

6 (67)

 SD

28.63

15.89

28.10

  

 Min

7.94

57.79

10.26

  

Center size: < 22,075 (n = 8)

 Mean

17.70

74.88

22.38

4 (50)

4 (50)

 SD

15.00

22.70

16.41

  

 Min

2.91

46.75

5.88

  

Center size: ≥ 22,075 (n = 8)

 Mean

33.63

78.76

40.42

3 (38)

5 (62)

 SD

30.38

24.66

27.41

  

 Min

7.94

39.20

10.26

  

Smoking prevalence: < 6.5% (n = 8)

 Mean

21.67

72.83

29.03

3 (38)

5 (62)

 SD

17.21

23.00

18.69

  

 Min

2.91

39.20

5.88

  

Smoking prevalence: ≥ 6.5% (n = 8)

   

4 (50)

4 (50)

 Mean

29.65

80.81

33.77

  

 SD

30.99

23.80

29.06

  

 Min

5.69

46.75

10.69

  
  1. CRS Constant returns to scale, DRS Decreasing returns to scale, SD Standard deviation, VRS Variable returns to scale