Skip to main content

Table 3 Aim 3 evaluation

From: An effectiveness-implementation hybrid trial of phone-based tobacco cessation interventions in the Lebanese primary healthcare system: protocol for project PHOENICS

 

Measures

Instrument/data source

Timing

Fidelity

Provider training attendance and quality

Training log/evaluations

Pre-trial

Patients received Ask, Advise, Assist or Ask, Advise, Connect

Patient surveys

0, 1 month

Counseling sessions completed, content

Phone log/checklist

Weeks 1–8

Patient used 4-week NRT. Fidelity score, sum 2–4 (range 0–3)

Patient log

1 month

Adaptations

Timing, planning level, decision maker, modification, delivery level, context, content, fidelity, reason. Adaptation occurred (0/1)

Provider interviews and surveys

Pre-/post-trial

Sustainability capacity

Staff and leadership, stakeholders, monitoring/evaluation, planning/implementation, outcomes/effectiveness, workflow integration, organizational context/capacity. Overall score (range 1.0–7.0)

Provider surveys

Pre-/post-trial

Implementation context and outcomes

Outer setting (system resources, policies), inner setting (clinic priority, climate), provider (attitudes, knowledge, self-efficacy), implementation outcomes (acceptability, appropriateness)

Health admin. interviews

Post-trial

Provider interviews and surveys

Pre-/post-trial

  1. NRT Nicotine replacement therapy