Skip to main content

Table 2 Summary of intersections/overlaps in coding between individual CFIR and the six TDF domains

From: Mapping the Theoretical Domain Framework to the Consolidated Framework for Implementation Research: do multiple frameworks add value?

Key CFIR domains

Total coding with key TDF domains

Substantial intersection within CFIR constructs and TDF domains

Consistent intersection within CFIR constructs and TDF domains

Intervention Characteristics (IC) (N = 474)

382(81%)

Intervention source (5; 100%)

(Environmental context & resources (1;20%); Beliefs about capabilities (1;20%); Beliefs about consequences(2,40%); Behavioural regulation (1,20%)

Evidence Strength & Quality (84;76%)

(Environmental context & resources (11;13%); Beliefs about capabilities (9,11%); Beliefs about consequences (38;45%); Social influences (4,5%); Behavioural regulation (6;7%);

Social/professional role & identity (16;19%)

Relative Advantage (47;80%) (Environmental context & resources (16;34%); Beliefs about capabilities (7;15%); Beliefs about consequences (15;32%); Social influences (1;2%); Behavioural regulation (7;15%);

Social/professional role & identity (1;2%)

Adapatibility (102;82%)

(Environmental context & resources (37;36%); Beliefs about capabilities (8;8%); Beliefs about consequences (29;28%); Social influences (3;3%); Behavioural regulation (17;17%);

Social/professional role & identity (8;8%)

Complexity (61;82%)

(Environmental context & resources (9;15%); Beliefs about capabilities (7;11%); Beliefs about consequences (25;41%); Behavioural regulation (14;23%); Social/professional role & identity (6;10%)

Design Quality & Packaging (78;81%)

(Environmental context & resources (37;47%); Beliefs about capabilities (7;9%); Beliefs about consequences (16;21%); Social influences (3;4%); Behavioural regulation (11;14%);

Social/professional role & identity (4;5%)

Cost (5;100%)

(Environmental context & resources (1;20%); Beliefs about consequences (2;40%); Social/professional role & identity (2;40%)

N/A

Outer Setting (OS) (N = 247)

184 (74%)

External Policies and Incentives (6;100%)

(Environmental context & resources (1;17%); Beliefs about consequences (1;17%); Social influences (1;17%); Behavioural regulation (1;17%); Social/professional role & identity (2;33%)

Patient Needs & Resources (178;74%)

(Environmental context & resources (43;24%); Beliefs about capabilities (35;20%); Beliefs about consequences (43;24%); Social influences (8;5%); Behavioural regulation (28;16%); Social/professional role & identity (21;12%)

Inner Setting (IS) (N = 419)

306(73%)

Networks & Communication (35;71%)

(Environmental context & resources (7;20%); Beliefs about consequences (9;26%); Social influences (5;14%); Behavioural regulation (5;14%);

Social/professional role & identity (9;26%)

Implementation Climate (66;81%)

(Environmental context & resources (16;24%); Beliefs about consequences (15;23%); Social influences (2;3%); Behavioural regulation (15;23%);

Social/professional role & identity (18;27%)

Organisational Incentives & Rewards (27;82%)

(Environmental context & resources (9;33%); Beliefs about consequences (6;22%); Behavioural regulation (2;7%);

Social/professional role & identity (10;37%)

Available Resources (42;78%)

(Environmental context & resources (27;64%); Beliefs about consequences (4;10%); Social influences (2;5%); Behavioural regulation (3;7%);

Social/professional role & identity (6;14%)

Culture (27;63%)

(Beliefs about consequences (9;33%); Social influences (2;7%); Behavioural regulation (2;7%);

Social/professional role & identity (14;52%)

Tension for Change (7;54%)

(Environmental context & resources (2;29%); Beliefs about consequences (3;43%); Social/professional role & identity (2;29%)

Compatibility (42;68%)

(Environmental context & resources (1;2%); Beliefs about capabilities (3;7%); Beliefs about consequences (11;26%); Behavioural regulation (13;31%);

Social/professional role & identity 14;33%)

Relative Priority (20;71%)

(Environmental context & resources (4;20%); Beliefs about capabilities (2;10%); Beliefs about consequences (11;55%); Behavioural regulation 3;15%)

Access to knowledge/information (40;71%)

(Environmental context & resources (20;50%); Beliefs about capabilities (4;10%); Beliefs about consequences (6;15%); Social influences (2;5%); Behavioural regulation (2;5%);

Social/professional role & identity (6;15%)

Characteristics of Individuals (CI) (N = 600)

434(72%)

Knowledge & Beliefs (278;77%)

(Environmental context & resources (29;10%); Beliefs about capabilities (68; 24%); Beliefs about consequences (98;35%); Social influences (20;7%); Behavioural regulation (34;12%);

Social/professional role & identity (29;10%)

Individual Identification with the Organisation (70;72%)

(Environmental context & resources (4;22%); Beliefs about capabilities (1;6%); Beliefs about consequences (4;22%); Social influences (1;6%); Social/professional role & identity (8;44%)

Other Personal Attributes (31;91%)

(Environmental context & resources (5;16%); Beliefs about capabilities (7;23%); Beliefs about consequences (3;10%); Social influences (2;6%); Behavioural regulation 7;23%);

Social/professional role & identity (7;23%)

Individual Stage of Change (70;72%)

(Environmental context & resources (2;3%); Beliefs about capabilities (13;19%); Beliefs about consequences (26;37%); Social influences (5;7%); Behavioural regulation (11;16%);

Social/professional role & identity (13;19%)

Process (P) (N = 448)

339(76%)

Engaging (191;81%)

(Environmental context & resources (99;52%); Beliefs about capabilities (5;3%); Beliefs about consequences (18;9%); Social influences (15;18%); Behavioural regulation (16;8%);

Social/professional role & identity) (38;20%)

Planning (148;72%)

(Environmental context & resources (38;26%); Beliefs about capabilities (17;11%); Beliefs about consequences (19;13%); Social influences (4;3%); Behavioural regulation (45;30%); Social/professional role & identity (25;17%)